From Nagasakis cloud, to feeling explosive anger now
By Jerry Tallmer
For a week, every morning, just as I was waking up, washing up, putting the coffee in the microwave, these notes, this fragment of music, were running around, unidentified, in my head. Then bit by bit, some words started to come through, but idiot words . . .
...where the menfolk chew tobaccy ...
... then, another day, some further words ...
... and the women wicky wacky ...
And then one fine morning a day or two later still, I suddenly heard Benny Goodmans clarinet riding high over the whole thing, soaring up into the wild blue yonder, and I had it. Had it well enough to go to Google, here, today, at this computer, in this building straight across the avenue from the Hotel Pennsylvania, and dredge up Harry Warren and Mort Dixons (the words are Dixons) surreal 76-year-old hit song:
Hot ginger and dynamite
Theres nothing but that at night.
Back in Nagasaki where the fellers
And the women wicky wacky woo.
And now I know why that tune, those fragments of words, were chasing around my still half-asleep brain for a week or so of early mornings. It was because of the obituary Id read in the New York Times of July 19, about a man named Charles Sweeney.
The song, Nagasaki was brought forth by Warren and Dixon in 1928, and received its most famous recording in November 1937, by the Benny Goodman Quartet, in the Madhattan Room of the Hotel Pennsylvania. It was about as much as any American, except perhaps a missionary or two, could have told you in those years about the city on the other side of the world that Major Charles W. Sweeney and crew would visit from 17,000 feet above sea level on a Thursday morning in August not many years later.
On that Thursday morning, as it happens, August 9,1945, a somewhat smaller and considerably slower aircraft, a B-24, or flying boxcar, was also on a bombing mission over Japan, flying up the coast toward a target somewhat south of Tokyo but 135 miles north of Nagasaki. A B-24 could not attain the altitude of a B-29; this particular B-24, with an undressed lady and Pacific Passion painted on its nose, was at 10,000 feet just then, when Max, the tail-gunner, gave a scream over the intercom and, as Captain Arthur George briefly banked the aircraft, one could see in the clear blue sky (as clear and blue as a Tuesday morning in September in the year 2001) all the way back those 135 miles to the mushroom cloud boiling up to at least the 10,000 feet the B-24 was at, and something more.
The bomb had been released over Nagasaki at 11:01 a.m. on August 9, 1945, 59 years ago this Friday. Some 40,000 people died in that instant or soon thereafter; some 25,000 were, as the word goes, injured. A great many more than that had died or might have wished to have died in another Japanese city three days earlier.
It can be argued and has been argued that Hiroshima was necessary; that, on net, the Hiroshima atom bomb saved hundreds of thousands if not millions of lives, ours and theirs. It can also be argued and has been argued that Nagasaki was a war crime a hell that could have been dropped next to but not on Nagasaki, to make the same point and (hopefully) achieve the same result: an end to the war.
There was a radio/radar man on that B-24 who, like his crewmates, glimpsed Nagasaki from 135 miles away, and he didnt like it then and doesnt like it now. Once, a few years later, when The New Yorker came out with its issue wholly devoted to John Herseys classic book, Hiroshima, the said former crew member had his nose buried in that issue of the magazine as he walked downtown into Times Square. When he came to the sentence: There, in the tin factory, in the first moment of the atomic age, a human being was crushed by books, he shuddered, experienced tears, looked up and found himself smack in the middle of the junction of Broadway and Seventh Avenue, with cars ripping by on all sides.
Thirty years after Nagasaki, the same onetime Pacific Passion crew member wrote a short editorial in a New York daily newspaper recalling that instant in the B-24 as looking into the face of original sin. The owner of the newspaper made him append his initials, but she printed it.
So here we are, going on another 30 years and a whole world later still. Nicholas D. Kristof had a column in The Times last week about a Sgt. Donald Wallace of Salem, Oregon, who was perhaps the real hero of the Jessica Lynch shootout. When he ran out of ammunition he was, the Army believes, captured by the Fedayeen, stripped naked, handcuffed and killed.
Journalist Kristof paid a call on Norman and Arlene Walters, the sergeants parents. Red, white, and blue are everywhere in Mr. and Mrs. Walterss house, Kristof wrote, and Mr. Walters says that if he were president, he would threaten to nuke Baghdad unless the insurgency stopped, although in his next breath he backs out.
Lets put aside the third-person. I know exactly how Mr. Walters feels, and every time theres now a beheading or a beheading threatened, promised, take your choice in what we may as well call over there, I feel that way too. Worldwide Islamic fundamentalist terror-driven lunacy has opened the great stone gates to thinking the unthinkable. What price now, original sin?
In his memoir, Wars End, published in 1997, former B-29 pilot Charles Sweeney declared that, upon a visit to Nagasaki a few years after VJ Day, he took no pride or pleasure then, nor do I take any now, in the brutality of war . . . Every life is precious . . . But I felt no remorse or guilt that I had bombed the city where I stood.
Hot ginger and dynamite
Theres nothing but that at night.
On July 16, 2004, Maj. Gen. Charles W. Sweeney (ret.), a native of Lowell, Mass., died, at 84, in Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston. Nobody remembered the song Nagasaki anymore.