Villager online EXTRA
Restoration of CHARAS building called a façade to block landmarking
By Lincoln Anderson
As the nonprofit group that had been exploring building a 23-story dormitory on E. Ninth St. announced it is pulling out of the project, opponents of the plan last week uncovered potentially a new threat: a permit issued for repairs and restoration of the façade of the old school building on the site.
Dorm opponents fear the façade work is an effort to block landmarking of the former P.S. 64 so the landlord can demolish it and build the tower. On the other hand, landmarking the existing building would block construction of the tower.
Filed by SLCE Architects for 605 E. Ninth St., owned by Gregg Singer, the plans call for removal of almost all the exterior ornamentation mainly around windows above the first floor of the five-story, turn-of-the-century building. The Department of Buildings approved the plans on May 5. The applicant began filing the plans in March 2003, meaning the current permit is technically a renewal, according to D.O.B.
Referring to work
to be demolished the plans state intention to: Remove existing cast-stone veneer, pediments, keystones and cornices from façade, patch and prep subsurface to receive brick veneer; and Remove existing copper fascia/coping edge [along cornice line] and replace with aluminum coping.
The permit states the cost of the façade demolition as $600,000, which Ilyse Fink, Buildings director of communications, said sounds about right for the amount of work. On the other hand, she said a full exterior renovation would be very expensive.
Jennifer Givner, a Buildings spokesperson, said a sidewalk construction shed would have to be erected for the exterior work. The building doesnt fall under Local Law XI, which requires that landlords of buildings over six stories keep their facades safe.
Michael Rosen, of Stop the Dorm/Save Our School, uncovered the plans through his contacts as a former developer, and sounded the alarm. Stop the Dorm has sent thousands of petition signatures collected from Tompkins Sq. Park to Avenue D to Robert Tierney, Landmarks Preservation Commission chairperson, calling for the turn-of-the-century building to be landmarked. S.T.D. supports returning the building to use as a community arts center.
Clearly, demolition is being done under the guise of renovation, said Rosen. Absolutely nothing is being repaired here or restored. This is absolutely the destruction of a New York treasure.
Rosen called the façade work an aggressive tactic that property owners have been known to use in New York City to block preservation attempts.
East Village is landmark deprived
He said the old P.S. 64 building, designed by noted public schools architect Charles B.J. Snyder during the golden age of school construction, is worthy of landmarking on its merits. (Snyder was renowned for his distinctive, H-shaped school buildings.) Plus, the East Village, which lacks a historic district, has been neglected by Landmarks, Rosen added.
Weve looked at [the former] Stuyvesant High School, which is also a Snyder building, and theres no way that building outshines this building, Rosen said. Very, very few things in this neighborhood are landmarked. This neighborhood is very underrepresented in terms of landmarks.
Andrew Berman, executive director of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, said landlords will sometimes make last-minute exterior changes either to avoid being in historic districts or, at least, not have to maintain historic facades. Berman noted that right before the Gansevoort Historic District was designated last year, some Meat Market property owners illegally removed metal canopies.
Singer, however, variously claimed to not really know what was going on and that the repairs were being done for the tenant, which he doesnt yet have. He said he couldnt explain the work in detail, but that his in-house contractor could, but that the contractor isnt comfortable talking to the press. Meanwhile, Donald Gabbay, of Plaza Construction, another developer identified by Rosen as involved with the work, declined comment when called by The Villager.
Thats something that sounds like the condition of the building, Singer offered, referring to the façade work permit. Its dangerous. Stuff could be falling down. Its an old building.
Added Singer, If the city wanted to landmark it, they wouldve landmarked it a long time ago. They owned it all these years
. I didnt buy a landmarked building. (Singer bought the property at auction for $3.125 million five years ago.)
People cant afford to renovate the building now how are they going to afford to renovate it if its landmarked? he asked.
For now, Singer said he is keeping open both options of building University House at Tompkins Square the 700-plus-room student dorm and finding nonprofit tenants for the existing former public school building.
Whatever comes first the dorm or the tenant, he said. Constructing the dorm depends on state Dormitory Authority bonds being issued through legislation in Albany, which both State Senator Martin Connor and Assemblymember Steve Sanders oppose.
Not taking the bonds rebuff lightly, Singer said he has a local operative, whom he didnt name, who will expose Sanders and Connor.
Well go public and good luck to them at election time, Singer warned.
As for tenants, Singer says hes been unable to find any in five years and that the community should help find him one. Yet, Stop the Dorm members contend a dance/spiritual group offered Singer $20 million to buy the building and that, more recently, a dance group offered $40 million. Singer denied knowledge of the offers and reiterated he didnt buy the building to sell it, but to lease it.
Asked if he would consider scaling back the dorms size, Singer said he did that six months ago, reducing it from 27 to 23 stories, which he said is the ideal height for the project to work and cant be lower.
As usual, Singer blasted and belittled his opponents, calling Councilmember Margarita Lopez a fraud, the information on Stop the Dorms Web site made up, CHARAS, the arts organization he evicted from 605 E. Ninth St. over two years ago, just a name there is no such thing, and Susan Howard of Save CHARAS a joke.
Asked if he was still working with the nonprofit group National Development Council on developing the dorm, Singer, as of last week, didnt say that their relationship was ended.
N.D.C. want the community to meet with them and if the community doesnt want to meet with them, they dont know what to do, Singer stated.
N.D.C.: Were outta here
However, speaking on Tuesday, Daniel Marsh, of N.D.C., said they are no longer working with Singer on the dorm and have given up trying to reach out to the community to devise an alternative project for the site. Marsh said the community clearly didnt want to hear from them and that East Villagers angry opposition left N.D.C. reeling. In short, theyve thrown in the towel.
We never had made a decision to move ahead with the project, Marsh said. And when things got out of hand we decided not to proceed. There were so many discussions and fabrications on Web sites that were not true
. We can only stand so much. We entered our process with good intentions and before we even had a chance to talk to anyone we were maligned. Our involvement was not going to be received very well, in our mind.
Asked when N.D.C. decided to pull out, Marsh said, it was two weeks ago, about the time the community was making fun of our chairman [Samuel Beard] and maligning him.
He said, N.D.C. will move on to other projects theyre working on, like building a new magnet school in Hartford.
Councilmember Lopez noted she had had a meeting scheduled on Monday with Marsh, but he cancelled.
Eric Lugo, Lopezs chief of staff, who spoke with N.D.C. about the cancellation, said he understood they had backed out of the project.
They got hit so hard on the dormitory thing that they dont want to do anything, he said.
Meanwhile, Lopez attacked Singer for trying to demolish the façade of the former CHARAS/El Bohio.
One more time I am in disbelief at the attempt to destroy this historical building, said Lopez. First he buys this building, even though it was for community use. Now he tries to destroy the value of the building.
Lopez contacted Buildings Commissioner Patricia Lancaster, protesting that its illegal for Singer to get a permit to demolish the façade when the building is being considered for landmark status.
This is outrageous the Buildings Department is not seeing clearly what this is about, Lopez told The Villager.
However, D.O.B. spokespersons said if the building isnt landmarked or calendared for a hearing before the Landmarks Preservation Commission they cant stop either the permit being issued or the work being done.
Asked where the request for designating 605 E. Ninth St. a city landmark stood, Diane Jackier, a Landmarks spokesperson said, We received a request for evaluation and this is under review. Asked if there were instances when an emergency stop-work order could be put on a potential landmark, Jackier said she was only giving the one comment.
Stop the Dorm reportedly had a meeting, closed to the press, Tuesday night at Two Boots Video/Den of Cin on Avenue A to come up with a plan for reusing the existing P.S. 64 building.
At its full board meeting on Monday night, Community Board 3 passed the following resolution regarding the CHARAS site/University House development: 1) To strongly support the designation of the Beaux-Arts building at 605 E. Ninth St. a landmark; 2) to, once again, condemn the underhanded disposition of the building [by the city] to Gregg Singer, which has endangered its use as a community facility, and 3) to observe that the ramp constructed at the building is a paradigm of handicap construction.