Volume 77 / Number 38 - Feb. 20 - 26, 2008
West and East Village, Chelsea, Soho, Noho, Little Italy, Chinatown and Lower East Side, Since 1933

Talking point

Firewall cracked, Clinton counts on superdelegates

By Ben Goddard

Like a circus performer trying to spin one too many plates on poles, Hillary Clinton’s campaign is having trouble managing its messages lately. Oh, the candidate is sticking with the plan in her stump speeches; it’s when she and her shuffled staff try to explain the progress of her campaign that they’re having trouble keeping their spin straight. Let’s see, Obama’s early primary wins don’t count because independents could vote and it takes real Democrats to win the nomination. Then his sweep of caucus states should be ignored because only Democratic activists turned out. And then none of it mattered because when Bill Clinton ran in 1992 he lost all those states but still wound up winning the presidency. It is the big states where the delegates are, and Clinton has a lock on those, especially ones with large Hispanic populations and blue-collar Democrats.

That lock didn’t look so secure after the Potomac primaries. Clinton continued to win a majority of white women; but in both Virginia and Maryland Obama not only held the support that has propelled him this far but expanded his coalition deep into Clinton territory. He won among all women nearly 60 percent to 40 percent, got a similar margin among voters making less than $50,000 per year and even won Latinos by 10 points. Granted, the Latino population in Virginia and Maryland is only a fraction of what it is in Texas, but there was a clear crack in that Clinton firewall.

A lot can happen between now and March 4, as we’ve seen throughout this election year. But if these trends continue, Texas and Ohio start to look very competitive. Obama’s victories in rural states demonstrate he has appeal outside of upscale urban areas. (One big surprise on Super Tuesday was Idaho, a state popularly known for potatoes and neo-Nazis. Obama won 80 percent of the vote there. Not a lot of delegates, but a clear indication that the West is changing and that a new face can find a lot of support in red states.)

So now the Clinton spin has turned to delegates. No longer able to claim a lead after Obama’s recent string of victories has given him a 25-delegate advantage, according to The Associated Press, Hillary’s campaign has begun to talk about her superdelegate lead. Of the 796 such delegates, she claims 242 to Obama’s 160. If that proportional spread remains, we could see a repeat of the 1984 convention when former Vice President Walter Mondale overpowered then-Senator Gary Hart with superdelegates to win the nomination.

Except that a couple of things are different this year. First, there are signs that the Clinton campaign has collected all the low-hanging fruit — that those who have not yet committed are either truly open to either candidate or reluctant to sign on with the Clintons. Their team has been working those delegates very hard, in classic Clinton style. The former president is said to have had an angry exchange with New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson, a former Democratic presidential candidate himself. Richardson was refusing to commit. “What, isn’t two cabinet posts enough?” screamed the former president. There are a lot of these delegates who want to keep their options open despite a long history with the Clintons — or because of it, some insiders say. They may not be committed to Obama yet, but they are keeping their options open.

And well they should. So far Senator Obama has won 23 of 35 state contests and a majority of delegates elected in caucuses and primaries. He has brought millions of new, excited and engaged voters into the process. Should he go to the convention with more popular votes and more elected delegates but still be short of the nomination, we may well see a civil war in Denver. If party officials, officeholders and other superdelegates turn their backs on “the will of the people” and throw their support to Senator Clinton, there could be disastrous results. Most Democratic voters would fall in line and support the nominee, even if she had not won her delegates at the ballot box. But many would see such a result as a replay of the 2000 election when a handful of appointed Supreme Court justices gave the presidency to George W. Bush. A Florida outcome in Denver will not send the right message to the American people, and could well send a lot of impassioned Obama voters looking for an alternative. President Bloomberg, anyone?

Reader Services


Email our editor ARCHIVES

Support the Advertisers who support us!

The Villager is published by Community Media LLC. 145 Sixth Avenue, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (212) 229-1890 | Fax: (212) 229-2790 | Advertising: 646-452-2465 | © 2008 Community Media, LLC

Written permission of the publisher must be obtained before any of the contents of this newspaper, in whole or in part, can be reproduced or redistributed.