Volume 76, Number 6 | June 28 - July 4 2006


The public needs time to review memorial report

The words “finally settled” will not be able to be applied to World Trade Center questions for a very long time, but last week Frank Sciame did open the way for progress on the memorial. Sciame’s report to the governor and mayor outlining $285 million worth of cost savings makes it a more doable project.

The fact that Sciame was able to produce a substantive document and somehow avoid angering any major W.T.C. constituency is a remarkable achievement in itself. The changes he is recommending – moving the names up to street level to avoid building underground galleries, reducing the size of the 9/11 museum and combining it with the visitors center — retain the best parts of the design by Michael Arad and Peter Walker and get the budget down to high, but manageable levels. Sciame and the consultants who donated their time to produce the recommendations deserve the gratitude of the city and the country.

There is still a fight with the Port Authority over the memorial’s infrastructure costs; the estimated price of the direct memorial costs is a massive $768 million; the hidden costs are in the hundreds of millions and may never be calculated; part of the memorial still may be subjected to an entrance fee; and there is still a dispute about how the names will be listed, but the changes should allow construction to begin soon. Next month is too quick, though.

Gov. Pataki and Mayor Bloomberg gave Sciame the assignment and were able to ask him questions throughout his month-long analysis, but the public, with none of the advantages of the governor and mayor, only had seven days to comment. There was no public hearing, no community presentation and no chance for people to get answers directly from officials.

We are anxious to get more construction going at the site too, and we understand the need for family members to have a permanent memorial, but if it opens on 10/11/09 instead of 9/11/09 it is a small price to pay to insure broad-based support. There are still questions to be answered.

The changes do look better. It is now a memorial that will be able to function all year round. Putting the names over the memorial’s waterfalls means visitors will not get wet reading the names on windy days. Sciame’s construction cuts have even led to savings on the annual maintenance fees of $11.6 million, which in the long run will be a bigger benefit to the public.

Although we originally thought Bloomberg and Community Board 1 were right to recommend moving the memorial museum to the Freedom Tower, we accept Sciame’s conclusion that it would not save much money and would lead to other problems. Keeping the tower free of an essential component of the W.T.C. site could also free the next governor to cut off the hemorrhaging dollars being thrown at the tower and allow the market to have more of a say as to when this building should be built.

The governor and mayor should act like they think they have a good plan, extend the deadline and direct the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation to present it to the people, rather than continue to rush it through without review.

Reader Services


Email our editor



The Villager is published by
Community Media LLC.

145 Sixth Avenue, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (212) 229-1890 Fax: (212) 229-2790
Advertising: (646) 452-2465 •
© 2006 Community Media, LLC

Email: news@thevillager.com

Written permission of the publisher must be obtainedbefore any of the contents of this newspaper, in whole or in part, can be reproduced or redistributed.