B.P. race: Lappin meets and greets; Post blasts Menin

At Thursday’s meet-and-greet in the Village for Jessica Lappin, from left, Gary Ginsberg, Jessica Lappin and Bob Kerrey.  Photos by Lincoln Anderson

At Thursday’s meet-and-greet in the Village for Jessica Lappin, from left, Gary Ginsberg, Jessica Lappin and Bob Kerrey. Photos by Lincoln Anderson

BY LINCOLN ANDERSON  |   Trying to make inroads with Downtown community leaders, borough president candidate Jessica Lappin held a meet-and-greet with a small but influential group of about 30 people at the Village home of Susanna Aaron and Gary Ginsberg on Monday evening.

Standing midway up a staircase leading up from the living room, Lappin addressed her audience for about 20 minutes, laying out some of her key campaign positions and concerns, then took questions and mingled with the crowd as they sipped wine and snacked on cheese and grapes.

The gathering — which was not a fundraiser — was heavy on Community Board 2 members and local Hudson River Park activists, and notably included Madelyn Wils, the president and C.E.O. of the Hudson River Park Trust.

Also attending was former U.S. Senator Bob Kerrey. The former New School president said he is endorsing Lappin.

As a condition for The Villager being invited to attend, the Lappin campaign requested that the substance or her remarks at the gathering be off the record.

From left, Bob Kerrey, Susanna Aaron, Susan Caccappolo and her son Rich Caccappolo.

From left, Bob Kerrey, Susanna Aaron, Susan Caccappolo and her son Rich Caccappolo.

Elected to the City Council in 2005, Lappin represents the Upper East Side between 49th and 92nd Sts. She formerly chaired the Council’s Land Use Subcommittee on Landmarks, Public Siting and Maritime Uses.

A native New Yorker and lifelong Democrat, Lappin attended UNIS (United Nations International School) — which Aaron also attended — and Stuyvesant High School.

The three other candidates in the race are Councilmembers Gale Brewer and Robert Jackson and former Community Board 1 Chairperson Julie Menin.

The borough president appoints community board members, issues advisory opinions on land-use projects and has a sizable staff.

Ginsberg, formerly Rupert Murdoch’s right-hand man at News Corp., is currently a top executive at Time Warner. Aaron, a former TV producer, is a board of directors member of the Friends of Hudson River Park.

Chris McGinnis, left, a board member of Greenwich Village Little League, and Coral Dawson of C.B. 2 were also at the Lappin event.

Chris McGinnis, left, a board member of Greenwich Village Little League, and Coral Dawson of C.B. 2 were also at the Lappin event.

Aaron said she sent invitations to all 50 members of Community Board 2. She also invited parents from the Village Community School, where her youngest son is currently a student.

She said her being on the board of Friends — the waterfront park’s leading private fundraising arm — is the reason she invited Wils. However, Wils said she had been “dragged” to the event by Rich Caccappolo, a Lappin booster and chairperson of C.B. 2’s Parks and Waterfront Committee.

As Wils was leaving the meet-and-greet, asked if she was throwing her support behind Lappin, she said, “No, I had a drink with Rich Caccappolo at a bar first and he asked me to come over… . There’s nothing here,” she said with a flick of her hand, as if to say, “There’s no story here.”

However, her presence did raise a few eyebrows.

“I didn’t expect to see Madelyn here,” remarked Pam Frederick, a board of directors member of the Trust and former C.B. 4 chairperson, who was schmoozing with David Gruber, C.B. 2 chairperson.

As for who she might support for B.P., Frederick said she’s undecided.

“Jessica and Julie — those are two good ones,” she said.

Caccappolo did the IT side of Kerrey’s recent losing Nebraska Senate campaign. Asked if he was supporting Lappin, Kerrey quipped, of course, because “her husband’s from Nebraska.”

“I think she’s a real fresh face and she’ll help get a contract with the teachers union,” he said, adding that otherwise $250 million for the city’s schools is at risk of being lost due to the current impasse over teacher evaluations.

“I’m not speaking against Julie or the other candidates,” said Kerrey. “There are other people I speak against — but not them.”

As for his own plans, he said he’s focusing on working to get reimbursements for pre-K — early childhood education.

And he added, “I got a book I gotta finish.”

New state Senator Brad Hoylman, who wasn’t at the meet-and-greet, also notably recently threw his support behind Lappin.

The former C.B. 2 chairperson told The Villager, “I endorsed Jessica Lappin because I’ve known her for more than a decade and think she’d make an excellent borough president. Jessica is someone who has gotten results on key issues, such as new public schools, senior issues and open space, and is a true progressive who shares my values on a woman’s right to choose, the environment, tenants’ rights and L.G.B.T. issues.”

Other C.B. 2 members at last Thursday evening’s gathering at Aaron and Ginsberg’s place included Tobi Bergman, Maury Schott, Heather Campbell and Coral Dawson.

Campbell — who was active in the fight to save the Children’s Aid Society on Sullivan St. — said she had been impressed by Lappin’s tough questioning on New York University’s 2031 mega-project last year at the City Council’s marathon hearing on the hotly debated plan.

Dawson — who is poised to launch a new Downtown Parks Foundation — said of Lappin, “I just met her tonight, so I appreciated learning what I did. I want to get to know all the candidates.”

Meanwhile, on Sunday, in what some are dubbing a “hit piece,” the New York Post reported that Menin switched political parties three times in the span of 17 months, charging that she did so to raise her political profile. Menin was registered as a Democrat in November 2001, then in February 2002 registered with the Independence Party, only the next month to switch to Republican, and in July 2003 back to being a Democrat again.

During her G.O.P. stint, Menin was named by Republican Governor George Pataki to the powerful Lower Manhattan Development Corporation, the post-9/11 Downtown rebuilding agency.

Brewer blasted Menin’s party hopping as “opportunistic,” saying, “[Voters] should evaluate someone who’s switched parties that often.”

Lappin and Jackson declined to comment for that article.

Menin’s spokesperson, George Arzt, told the Post, that Menin has “been a Democrat for all but a year and a half of her last 27. In 2002, she was working 24/7 with the [Republican Pataki] administration to help rebuild Downtown. She thought she could help her community by showing her support for the state administration’s rebuilding efforts.”

However, leaders of local Democratic political clubs played down Menin’s party switches.

“It’s not an issue for me,” said Tony Hoffman, president of Village Independent Democrats. “I like both Julie and Jessica. Very honestly, if either of them were borough president, we’d be in very good shape. Brewer and Jackson are good, too.

“Every candidate has their strengths and every candidate has their weakness in their background,” Hoffman noted. “There’s no perfect person. Jessica and Julie are doing good things, they’d make good leaders. Julie has been a terrific public servant and [as a volunteer community board member] she didn’t get paid for it — so if she flip-flopped… .”

Hoffman said V.I.D. is “wide open” on who it will endorse for borough president.

Jeanne Wilcke, president of Downtown Independent Democrats, said local politicos already knew Menin wasn’t always a Democrat.

“Old news,” she said, “and the party registration changes were over a decade ago. The New York Post article read like a setup by a political rival. I guess someone is desperately afraid Menin may win. What I care about is what Menin has done for us.

“She called out when everyone else had their eyes closed on the L.M.D.C. and the hundreds of millions they were hoarding from 9/11 funds,” Wilcke noted.

“She wasn’t afraid to step in and address thorny issues, like Occupy Wall Street or the mosque while others were scratching their heads what to do.

“The 9/11 trials got moved from Downtown New York City after she started the ball rolling.

“When N.Y.U. applied for its big land grab further north, folks out of her area pleaded for help,” Wilcke added. “She lobbied N.Y.U. to move to the Financial District instead of crush Greenwich Village. Most other elected officials were nowhere to be seen.”

Plus, Wilcke added, “I too was a Republican once.” She said she registered with the G.O.P. when she worked in the finance industry.

“No clearheadedness to it, just everyone around me was Republican,” she said. “After awhile, I saw the light and switched to Democrat sometime in the early 1990s, I think. Anyway, we all have our stories and histories. The question to these candidates is — what have you done for me and the community?”

The Villager encourages readers to share articles:

Comments are often moderated.

We appreciate your comments and ask that you keep to the subject at hand, refrain from use of profanity and maintain a respectful tone to both the subject at hand and other readers who also post here. We reserve the right to delete your comment.

6 Responses to B.P. race: Lappin meets and greets; Post blasts Menin

  1. First let me correct one mistake, Jessica Lappin is not term limited. Secondly, I was aware Julie Menin had changed parties 10 years ago. She never tried to hide it. I am a life long and proud Democrat. That said, I don't vote only on party affiliation. I vote on what a candidate has done with their life. Julie has never waivered on her support of freedom of speech and religion. She supported both OWS and the Mosque when it wasn't popular with many lower Manhattan residents. Julie has spoken out for issues like a living wage, paid sick leave, affordable housing, marriage equality. The list goes on and on. No matter which party she registered with she has always been a true progressive and that's what counts.

  2. Raymond W. Cline

    A few months ago, Councilmember Lappin called me and asked me to support her bid for Manhattan Borough President. She spent several minutes listing her credentials. When she finished, I asked her directly why she voted Yes on the NYU 2031 Plan which will destroy Greenwich Village. She mumbled something about Christine Quinn wanting the 2031 Plan to go forward. The conversation didn’t last much longer. I never got the chance to discuss why she voted for a third term for Councilmembers and Mayor Bloomberg, though I suspect she might have said something about the mayor and Speaker wanting that to go through also. Looking back on the discussion, I should have asked Ms. Lappin about the Daily News’ slush fund article from June 1, 2009 entitled “City Council members get campaign contributions from nonprofit organizations they funded” and how her campaign received almost $12,000 from a school’s board she had obtained $15,000 for.

    If Ms. Lappin called me today, I would ask her to explain a few other things, such as NYC Campaign Finance Board’s data showing that Howard Milstein bundled $50,450 for her, and Frank Sciame of FJ Sciame Construction got her $16,000. I could go on about the money that Tishman, the Goren Group and other real estate concerns got her, but readers can see for themselves and think about Ms. Lappin’s development leanings.

    I’m just not impressed with Ms. Lappin’s tough questioning of NYU 2031 at the Council’s public hearing – posturing means nothing unless you act on what you say. The truth is she voted to approve something that will irrevocably hurt my community. I don’t see how anyone in Greenwich Village could reward her with a vote.

    As for Julie Menin changing political parties briefly some 10 years ago, I’ve been active in the Democratic Party for a very long time and have helped many Democrats get into office. I’ve talked about the virtues of being a Democrat more times than I can recall. Yet if asked “are you voting for the party or the person,” I vote for the person. Ms. Menin changed parties in order to help her community in the 9/11 aftermath. Ed Koch once described himself as a common-sense liberal to describe his thought process. Julie Menin displays the same kind of common sense and dedication to her constituents.

  3. Cline in wrong about at least one thing–Lappin voted against giving Bloomberg a 3rd term. I keep a list of how each City Council member voted handy, so I know I'm correct about this. I can't confirm the accuracy of anything else Cline said but given this egregious error, I suggest that some fact checking is in order.

  4. General interest newspapers typically publish stories on local and national political events and personalities, crime, business, entertainment, society and sports. Thanks. school application letter

  5. Your blog is beautiful thank you very much for your share.You can also to look at my home page maybe have what you like.

  6. In response to the early criticisms of the trait approach, theorists began to research leadership as a set of behaviors, evaluating the behavior of successful leaders, determining a behavior taxonomy, and identifying broad leadership styles. Thanks a lot.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


seven + = 15

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>