Yo, people! Downshift bus fury, steer the process, member says

The city’s initial approval of a bus stop on Essex St. for the new Yo! Bus line infuriated Lower East Siders.

BY SAM SPOKONY  |  It’s been more than a week since Lower East Side residents and politicians fought off an intercity bus company’s attempt to place a loading stop outside Seward Park — a tense struggle that culminated in a surprising reversal by the city’s Department of Transportation.

D.O.T. had initially granted Greyhound a six-month permit to launch its new YO! Bus service at the curb at 3 Essex St., amid protests from neighborhood residents and an outright denial of the proposal by Community Board 3. But the agency switched gears days after Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, state Senator Dan Squadron and City Councilmember Margaret Chin sent a letter urging D.O.T. to reconsider the location. The permit was rescinded, leaving Greyhound empty-handed at the eleventh hour.

Many residents immediately celebrated their victory on local blogs, and the politicians lauded the grassroots effort in a joint announcement of the news, saying, “Our community has spoken loudly and clearly.”

But this week David Crane, head of the C.B. 3 committee that recommended against Greyhound’s plan, told this newspaper he thinks area residents need to refocus their priorities in future struggles as low-cost buses continue to spread in Chinatown and beyond.

“Two hundred fifty angry people at a meeting isn’t going to work once the legislation is in effect,” said Crane, who chairs C.B. 3’s Transportation Committee. “It’s not productive for the community board simply to discuss where there should or shouldn’t be a stop; we should be talking about how the industry is organized and regulated.”

The legislation he referred to — which creates the first-ever permit system for intercity buses that make curbside pickups — was authored by Silver and Squadron, signed by Governor Cuomo in August and will go into effect in several months. The new rules will, among other things, require the city to consult with local community boards before issuing or amending a bus-stop permit, including a 45 day notice and comment period.

Crane stressed that while the law’s community input elements are positive steps, they might be misleading to residents who believe that they can keep new buses off their streets simply by voting down proposals.

“People tend to forget that everything we do is advisory,” he said. “In the end, D.O.T. will always be able to put in the stops they want. They’re free to ignore our advice.”

So instead of just expressing their disapproval for a certain location, he added, residents need to be more concerned with lobbying for reasonable restrictions on bus permits — elements such as pollution-control devices, garbage collection or the number of trips per day.

Compiling a hefty list of recommended restrictions was one of Crane’s primary goals during the Sept. 11 meeting at which his committee put together its resolution on Greyhound’s plans for the Essex St. stop. But he barely had a chance to pursue that course of action, he explained, because many of the residents in attendance that night were so angry that they lost sight of the big picture.

“My committee was willing to work on stipulations to the permit that, if it were eventually approved, could have really had an effect on forcing the bus company to comply,” Crane said. “But every time we tried to bring it up, we were getting yelled down by various people. Some of them were just extremely rude.”

Aside from revealing a lack of courtesy, he concluded, that shortsightedness could actually leave residents worse off once the new permit legislation goes into effect. If the community board were to recommend few or no restrictions on a permit, bus companies would get somewhat of a free ride to further irk the local population if D.O.T. ended up approving the stop, regardless of the board’s overall resolution.

Crane will attempt to drive that perspective home on Oct. 10, when the next C.B. 3 Transportation Committee meeting will include a discussion of the guidelines for bus permit applications under the new legislation.

The Villager encourages readers to share articles:

Comments are often moderated.

We appreciate your comments and ask that you keep to the subject at hand, refrain from use of profanity and maintain a respectful tone to both the subject at hand and other readers who also post here. We reserve the right to delete your comment.

4 Responses to Yo, people! Downshift bus fury, steer the process, member says

  1. Whatever happened to bus depots??? If these big business buses want to pick up and drop off passengers, let them come together and rent a facility in the area. Why should they be able to do busines for free on our streets that we pay taxes to maintain??? I bet that a local parking lot operator would love to rent them some space, and maybe even add a new employee to handle their business (isn't employment what the economy needs?). Our local meter maid isn't letting me use the street for free and i pay my tickets, so why should these for-profit businesses get to idle for free and we upstairs breath their smog? They should be renting or buying a lot and paying their fair/fare share for it. They get to do business, the residents aren't suffering, and the economy benifits both locally and govt'mentally – it's a win, win, win.

  2. Shouldn't CB3's Transportation Subcommittee be representing community concerns rather than pushing its own agenda by shaming Lower East Siders into passively accepting new curbside bus stops? The tone in this article is rather ominous: to all those of you who opposed 'YO' Bus at the 911 CB3 meeting, don't think you can get away with this again! But if LES residents wind up objecting to certain future bus stop applications, it is their right to oppose them. This happens all the time in other Community Board areas, so why not here?

  3. Instead of a park up the middle of Allen Street, why not a center lane just for bus drops/pick-ups? Get the buses out of the moving traffic, and find a way to give them their own lanes where cars don't go. THEN TAX THEM FOR IT!!! Stop giving these bus companies the use of our streets for free.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


× 6 = forty two

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>